Version 22 of Practical Introduction to Upvar and Uplevel

Updated 2002-10-03 13:38:03

marsd wrote this and he's not proud.

I had a lot of trouble with upvar and uplevel up till a year or so ago so I figured I'd give a short overview of what I've learned of dealing with them.

I'll just use two basic proc's for this "tutorial":


Number One:(upvar)

 proc pass {val {bdy "puts $LOCAL"} {lvl "#0"}} {
    upvar $lvl $val LOCAL
    eval $bdy
 }

Description: A flexible proc that accepts various arguments:

val = the upvar variable to work with.

bdy = the commands to be executed..default is just to print to stdout the pointed variable.

lvl = what stacklevel do we want to work with?



Number two:(uplevel)

 proc putUp {cmd {lvl "#0"}} {
    uplevel $lvl "eval $cmd"
 }

Description: A flexible proc that evaluates $cmd at the lvl pointed stack. Disclaimer: I've got some negative feedback for using uplevel this way. Using uplevel this way WILL affect your program differently than using uplevel {command}. The method "cmd" allows transparent use of local and global variables, the other {cmd} causes problems with local variable evaluation. Maybe an expert could discuss the evaluation issue.


Notes on levels: The "lvl" default arg in both proc's refers to a "stack level", a reference to #0 means global, #1 is up one level, #2 up two. There is no converse. No downlevel. The examples given will work well enough for all stack levels.


Just Jump in here: Try running this example in tkcon or tclsh after loading the above procs into them.

 set x 12 

 pass x 

 putUp {puts $x}  

Well if you've worked with upvar and uplevel before you'll know that's what these commands do, and should probably be somewhere else ;)

You should get 12 for each.



Now we modify the values twice via both proc's:

 pass x {set LOCAL 3 ; puts $LOCAL ; putUp {set x 12}}

 puts $x

 putUp {set x 3 ; puts $x ; pass x {set LOCAL 12}}

 puts $x

Break the command down and try it piece by piece if you don't follow the above.



This one is simpler, unsetting x:

 pass x {unset LOCAL}

 set x 12

 putUp {unset x}


This one may be a little confusing:

 putUp {proc foo {{x} {puts $x ; pass x {set LOCAL 21} "#1"}}}

 rename foo ""

This calls the pass proc from a "dynamically" created proc named foo, created at the global stack level by the putUp proc.

The pass proc resets a variable passed to foo from global space and resets it at stack level 1, inside foo.

Control passes back and we destroy foo. A one shot wonder.

This is the real power of tcl illustrated. The flexibility of the language is amazing.



Finally:

Be aware that the info commands are very helpful in dynamically creating and keeping straight your processes called at various levels.

 set x 12

 pass x {puts "[[info level]], [[info level 1]]" ; set LOCAL 2}

The command {info level} tells what stack level the calling process is coming from. With the additional {info level "level"} arg the interpreter looks for any operations at that stack level.


Happy Tcling!

Good God this formatting is a bear!!!!