This is the implementation of the method invocation benchmark of [Tcl OO Bench] in various Tcl OO extensions. ---- [ITcl] package require Itcl itcl::class Toggle { variable state constructor {start_state} { set state $start_state } method value {} { return $state } method activate {} { set state [expr {!$state}] return $this } } itcl::class NthToggle { inherit Toggle variable count_max variable counter constructor {start_state max_counter} { Toggle::constructor $start_state } { set count_max $max_counter set counter 0 } method activate {} { if {[incr counter] >= $count_max} { Toggle::activate set counter 0 } return $this } } proc main {} { set n [lindex $::argv 0] set val 1 set toggle [Toggle #auto $val] for {set i 0} {$i < $n} {incr i} { set val [[$toggle activate] value] } if {$val} {puts "true"} else {puts "false"} set val 1 set ntoggle [NthToggle #auto 1 3] for {set i 0} {$i < $n} {incr i} { set val [[$ntoggle activate] value] } if {$val} {puts "true"} else {puts "false"} } main ---- [OTcl] Class Toggle Toggle instproc state {v} { $self set state $v } Toggle instproc value {} { $self set state } Toggle instproc activate {} { $self state [expr {! [$self set state]}] set self } Class NthToggle -superclass Toggle NthToggle instproc max {v} { $self set max $v } NthToggle instproc init args { eval $self next $args $self set counter 0 } NthToggle instproc activate {} { $self instvar counter if {[incr counter] >= [$self set max]} { $self next set counter 0 } set self } proc main {} { set n [lindex $::argv 0] set val 1 set toggle [Toggle n -state $val] for {set i 0} {$i < $n} {incr i} { set val [[$toggle activate] value] } if {$val} {puts "true"} else {puts "false"} set val 1 set ntoggle [NthToggle nn -state 1 -max 3] for {set i 0} {$i < $n} {incr i} { set val [[$ntoggle activate] value] } if {$val} {puts "true"} else {puts "false"} } main ----- [XOTcl] package require XOTcl; namespace import -force xotcl::* Class Toggle -parameter state Toggle instproc value {} { my state } Toggle instproc activate {} { my state [expr {! [my state]}] self } Class NthToggle -superclass Toggle -parameter max NthToggle instproc init {} { next my set counter 0 } NthToggle instproc activate {} { if {[my incr counter] >= [my max]} { next my set counter 0 } self } proc main {} { set n [lindex $::argv 0] set val 1 set toggle [Toggle new -state $val] for {set i 0} {$i < $n} {incr i} { set val [[$toggle activate] value] } if {$val} {puts "true"} else {puts "false"} set val 1 set ntoggle [NthToggle new -state 1 -max 3] for {set i 0} {$i < $n} {incr i} { set val [[$ntoggle activate] value] } if {$val} {puts "true"} else {puts "false"} } main [Category XOTcl Code] ----- [stooop] package require stooop namespace import stooop::* class Toggle { proc Toggle {this start_state} { set ($this,state) $start_state } proc ~Toggle {this} {} virtual proc value {this} { return $($this,state) } proc activate {this} { set ($this,state) [expr {!$($this,state)}] return $this } } class NthToggle { proc NthToggle {this start_state max_counter} Toggle {$start_state} { set ($this,count_max) $max_counter set ($this,counter) 0 } proc ~NthToggle {this} {} proc activate {this} { if {[incr ($this,counter)]>=$($this,count_max)} { set Toggle::($this,state) [expr {!$Toggle::($this,state)}] set ($this,counter) 0 } return $this } } proc main {n} { set val 1 set toggle [new Toggle $val] for {set i 0} {$i<$n} {incr i} { set val [Toggle::value [Toggle::activate $toggle]] } if {$val} {puts true} else {puts false} delete $toggle set val 1 set ntoggle [new NthToggle $val 3] for {set i 0} {$i<$n} {incr i} { set val [Toggle::value [NthToggle::activate $ntoggle]] } if {$val} {puts true} else {puts false} delete $ntoggle } main [expr {$argc==1?[lindex $argv 0]:1}] ----