Deployment is the work it takes to move from finished application to application working on the end-users desktop/server/other computer to
keeping the application up to date.
- Distribution Mechanisms
- from the WinTclTk project
- Building Stand Alone Executables in Unix
- with mktclapp
- Building Stand-Alone Tcl/Tk Applications under Mac OS X
- Critcl builds C extensions on-the-fly
- MicroTcl for Tcl9
- Jean-Claude Wippler
- James Garrison
- Script to merge C source files
- COMPANY: Career Demon.com plc
- Cameron Laird's personal remarks on deployment
- How to compile a TCL script into an EXE program
- A Poor Boy does Deployment
- the ravings (;-)) of Rohan Pall as he struggles to solve various deployment issues. This is a stream of conciousness description to show people that this stuff of putting an application on a desktop is non-trivial.
- One file to distribute instead of dozens of runtime scripts, shared libraries, etc.
- Decrease probability that the user will modify application (accidentally or intentionally)
- source protection
- Hide/obfuscate the algorithm being used in application
Issues to be considered
- On what platforms does the application need to run?
- Will the application and all of its dependencies run on these platforms?
- Where in the end-user's environment does the application and its components reside?
- How many of the application's dependant components do you need to deploy (your own tcl/tk interpreter? extensions, stand alone additional applications, images, fonts, drivers, libraries, etc.)?
- When a bug is encountered, how do you ensure that all end-users are updated appropriately?
- When end-users' versions of an application are updated, how to you ensure that data are properly updated?
- When end-users' versions of an application are updated, how to you ensure that they can revert to a prior version (when possible)?
- How can you determine how many end-users are using the application?
- Do the end-users need to share data, and if so, how do they do this?
- Are there any resource/locking issues with multiple accesses to the application or to the data (either multiple by one person, or multiple people accessing "simultaneously")?
- What permissions are required for the application to be installed - some systems require special permissions for registry updates, system wide directories to be updated, etc.?
- What special hardware needs must be met?
- What operating system / driver patches must be in place?
- In what format should the application and its components be shipped - Deployment file formats?
- How do you determine an accurate picture of important information by someone reporting a problem? For instance, what version of each component being used by the application, what platform, what patches, etc.?
- How are independent packages updated?
The Wikipedia has a serious page [1 ] on the topic.
- GE ICE Tcl compiler
- commercial product
- a different kind of approach; provides tools for creating your own C or C++ mainline which then invokes tcl functions.
- TOBE ("Tcl as One Big Executable")
- builds UNIX and Windows binaries
- shell script that creates self-extracting archives for all Unix platforms having a reasonable set of commands (tail, tar, sh, etc.)
Platform x tools availability table:
[BSD] [Linux] [Mac OSX] [Solaris] [Windows]
[Tclkit] yes yes yes yes yes
[Freewrap] ? yes ? ? yes
[TclPro]* ? yes ? ? yes
[Tcl Dev Kit] ? yes ? ? yes
[Mktclapp] ? yes ? ? ?
[GE ICE] ? ? ? ? ?
[TOBE] ? yes ? ? yes
[TclWrap]** ? yes ? ? yes
[Kt2c]*** ? ? ? ? ?
See source protection
Not all the methods described here provide the same level of protection for your scripts, so it is important to understand how they work and account for that against your protection needs. Many of the wrapping solutions only embed the same code in a binary, but that doesn't prevent others from unwrapping and reading it. Those solutions are good for general ease of use and development, but are best for preventing end users from tinkering with your code, as they don't provide a high level of protection.
Various tools exist for creating single-executable deployments:
- attempt to separate the runtime environment from the application environment; results in two files to distribute. One is platform specific but application neutral. The other is platform independent, but application specific.
- a standalone Tcl/Tk binary similar to Tclkit at http://www.endorser.org/cookit
- which works quite nicely
- proprietary, commercial, a component of Tcl Dev Kit
- open-source, free, a component of TclPro
- Wize - Wish Integrated Zip Executable
- yet another deployment method, along with a development environment
- the package that started it all
- Oct. 2006
- allows you to combine a number of files together to create a single tarcel file that can be run by tclsh, wish, or can be sourced into another Tcl script. In addition it allows you to easily create Tcl modules made up of several files including shared libraries.
- create standalone scripts, "final products", ready to be run anywhere Tcl and/or Tk is available.
FW: Note that the standard, officially advocated technique for bundling a Tcl interpreter and your script (and optionally even libraries etc) into a single executable is now Starpacks via TclKit. There's no longer a lack of a standard on the matter. The rest of these options have become esoteric in comparison. I believe even Tcl Dev Kit now uses Starpacks (I don't know what has become of the original wrapping tool - maybe included as well).
Of course, Starpacks are not only usually unobfuscated (and uncompiled), but tools are actually provided in the distro to unwrap them - so of these apps, the ones that actually do some compilation rather than just bundling still have a leg up on TclKit. But overall, for bundling, TclKit is now definitely the recommendation. It's a more standard and globally accepted method than is provided for any of the other major scripting languages.
Some work that has been done on the concept of a starkit allows one to build a 2 part install - a one piece interpreter with a number of extensions built in, and one file per application, which contains its own database. This addresses some of the concerns from users regarding multiple stand alone documents reproducing all of the window manager support multiple times, using up a LOT more disk space.
Traditional Tcl installation
Bob Techentin wisely observes, "You might consider a 'traditional' tcl/tk installation, complete [with] additional packages, as a component of your application. Take a close look at how TclPro tools get installed, and you'll see that the 'wish' executable is actually a short shell script which sets some environment variables (e.g., LD_LIBRARY_PATH) and then execs the binary shell."
Building Scripts into Tcl
Simply compiling the scripts into a stand alone intepreter (adding the scripts as a series of character strings into a simple mainline that then feeds them into the interpreter) won't hide them or even speed things up that much. This is is a crude but simple mechanism, but gets the job done. VFS-based analaogues such as starpacks are likely preferable.
Another option is to use Tclkit's starkit [2 ].
In a few steps:
- get Tclkit for your platform
- get the "SDX" scripted doc utility (platform independent) from [3 ]
- create dirs "myapp.vfs/", "myapp.vfs/bin/", and "myapp.vfs/lib/"
- copy your main script to "myapp.vfs/bin/main.tcl"
- copy all packages you need as dirs inside "myapp.vfs/lib/"
- wrap it all up using "sdx fs2sd myapp" ("file system to scripted doc")
- that's it, you have a runnable "myapp"
- try it (double-click, or run "./myapp" on Unix)
JCW: There are ways to make "main.tcl" work in unpackaged as well as in packaged form, which is useful for debugging. All of this is based on Tcl's Virtual File System or VFS in short. All examples here [5 ] and here [4 ] use this same approach, you can unpack them (with "sdx sd2fs ...") to see how they work.
Jeff Godfrey: "[W]ith the advent of starkit/starpack technology, deployment issues are mostly a thing of the past ..."
ActiveState's Tcl Dev Kit TclApp tool builds on starkit technology to make all the above a simple point-and-click exercise. It uses a file called basekit as its foundation.
Also be sure to check out the wondrous sample offerings at the Starkit Distribution Archive [6 ]
LV: What would be a good web site for someone attempting to get a handle on these types of issues, in cases where a starkit is not an option?